METHOD / EVIDENCE STANDARD

Define the question.
Then compare.

A useful ranking makes its unit of comparison visible. It does not ask a familiar name or a missing figure to stand in for evidence.

01 / SCOPE

Compare the same business.

Set the reporting unit, product boundary, market and period first. A group, brand and combined segment are not interchangeable. The pilot examines Singapore merchant-marine newbuilding and repair coatings in calendar 2025.

02 / MEASURE

One dimension, clearly labelled.

The pilot measure is net external sales revenue, not physical litres, revenue growth or product performance. No composite weights have been used. Currency conversion has not been registered or performed.

03 / SOURCES

Keep the original within reach.

Link the source, identify the relevant passage or page and label the reporting period, market, scope and nature of the evidence. A company statement remains a company statement. An accessible report directory is not a reviewed financial disclosure.

04 / GAPS & TIES

Do not manufacture precision.

Separate unavailable, out-of-scope, conflicting and not-applicable evidence. Missing values are excluded, not scored as zero. Equal disclosed values should tie; uncertain or indistinguishable results should not be forced into a winner.

05 / REVIEW

A reproducible result is only one check.

The source value, comparison rules and calculation need review. Repeating a calculation does not prove the input is true. Method changes should be explained, versioned and applied to every included business—not selected to improve one position.

06 / LIMITS

State what the order cannot tell you.

Sales context cannot establish system suitability, certification, service life, stock or a delivery commitment. The Singapore pilot remains unranked; the formal coverage rule and final scope are not frozen.

Read the current study